Eleven v4 vs MiniMax Speech 2.8
قارن النماذج
Eleven v4 is more worth it — 71% vs 61%
How we score worth-it? →ElevenLabs' flagship text-to-speech model — the most emotive, natural, multilingual voice synthesis.
- A lot of Substacks voiced by ElevenLabs models sound fine, with occasional weirdness around proper nouns.— hn ↗
- ElevenLabs still rules pretty much in this space — especially for non-English models.— hn ↗
- I listen to web novels with ElevenLabs Reader all the time — I love it.— hn ↗
- Now I can make voice packs for the unvoiced games one by one.— blog ↗
- Voice generation can no longer be told apart from a real person.— youtube ↗
- We use ElevenLabs in our Text-to-Video product, however the cost is extremely high.— reddit ↗
- Working great until last month — now v2 and v2.5 no longer produce good results and my cloned voice sounds flat and lifeless.— reddit ↗
- The problem is that its API format is one-of-a-kind, plus voices are restricted by language.— blog ↗
- The cons remain real: credits burn fast on retakes, accent drift still occurs on long narrations.— blog ↗
- so annoyoing you need to use tags.. Just let us talk in mic and clone the voice with that 'feeling', timing and emotions.— youtube ↗
“ElevenLabs still rules this space — especially for non-English models.”
“Voice generation can no longer be told apart from a real person.”
“The cost is extremely high.”
MiniMax's TTS voice model — high-fidelity cloning, studio-grade expression, first-class Asian language support.
- Everyone knows MiniMax, and it isn't just large language models — their TTS voice model is the best one I've tested to date.— blog ↗
- The timbre carries a lot more sibilance, its rhythm and pauses feel natural, and there's a sense of breath between the sentences.— blog ↗
- MiniMax was built with Asian language support as a first-class priority: Mandarin tones are accurate, Japanese particle pronunciation is clean, Korean sounds native.— blog ↗
- Control tags like clear-throat, coughs, and laughs all correctly produced the sound effects without being read aloud as text.— blog ↗
- With the same reference recording and three unseen lines, the voice owner chose MiniMax in all three listenings.— github ↗
- The laughs, throat-clearing tags pull you right out of it; they sound unnatural, so avoid them.— blog ↗
- MiniMax fell behind on voice-clone consistency compared to rivals that were almost indistinguishable from the real thing.— blog ↗
- Every update gets hyped to the skies, but in practice it never lives up to it.— other ↗
“MiniMax's TTS voice model is the best one I've tested to date.”
“Asian language support as a first-class priority: Mandarin tones accurate, Japanese and Korean sound native.”
“Clone consistency still has shortcomings, and reading symbols and technical terms is weak.”
FAQ
Is Eleven v4 or MiniMax Speech 2.8 more worth it?
Eleven v4 is more worth it, with a 71% worth-it score vs 61% for MiniMax Speech 2.8.
How much does Eleven v4 cost vs MiniMax Speech 2.8?
Eleven v4: $0.08/1K chars (v4) · $0.04/1K (v4 Turbo) · MiniMax Speech 2.8: ¥3.5/10K chars.
What do users say about Eleven v4 vs MiniMax Speech 2.8?
Eleven v4: ElevenLabs still rules this space — especially for non-English models.. MiniMax Speech 2.8: MiniMax's TTS voice model is the best one I've tested to date..