Gemini 4 Argon vs Gemini 4 Carbon
قارن النماذج
Gemini 4 Argon is more worth it — 40% vs 39%
How we score worth-it? →Cheapest frontier model, true multimodal
- It's comparable to Opus 5.5 on 'high' (54 vs 53; $1.82 vs $1.99), crushes every model except the most modern OAI/Ant ones, has _way_ lower hallucination than every existing model and probably broader support for multimodal like existing Gemini models.— hn
- The most impressive jump for me is in the low hallucination rate, which is specially impressive given how bad Gemini current models are on this regard— hn
- I even find Gemini 4 Argon more useful than Astra. Gemini is best at chatting and divergent thinking, with richer world knowledge and bolder ideas. Keep handing the backend engineering to GPT, but talk ideas and direction with Gemini.— other ↗
- Argon also has a big advantage in cybersecurity. GPT is okay, but Claude is unusable and instantly downgrades; so for some things I can only run them on Argon.— other ↗
- I think I still prefer something more creative.— other ↗
- It's not as smart as Claude Opus 5.5 High according to the AA benchmark. Looks like a big fat nothingburger so far, though it's possible that future fine-tuned checkpoints of the same pretrained model will do a lot better.— hn
- 5 points off Opus 5.5 on AA, not a good release. Falling behind and not able to catchup. Ant probably has opus 6 in the works. Fumbled so hard on this, they should have owned AI.— hn
- Trading punches in the benchmarks with Mimo v2.6 and 6.1-Sol (both very cheap!), and decidedly inferior to Opus 5.5. I'm afraid this looks unimpressive. Rather comical that they're delaying its launch 'for safety reasons'.— hn
- What a snooze fest. Another model that does not meaningfully improve on intelligence or price compared to its peers.— hn
- 80s pre-header timeout followed by 429 fallback and model cooldown.— github
“$2/$10 per million tokens is a steal for what you get. Cheapest frontier model by a mile.”
“The 1M context plus real multimodal input — I fed it a whole PDF manual plus screenshots and it nailed it.”
“But the first token takes forever. It 'thinks' for 5+ minutes sometimes and I thought it was broken.”
Google's strongest frontier model — tops Intelligence Index v5, state-of-the-art cybersecurity + long coding. Gated to cyber defenders.
- So more capable and the same price? I can at least appreciate that.— hn ↗
- Huge progress, wow — first place on the terminal bench science benchmark.— blog ↗
- I've been using Gemini 4 in AI Studio, and its human-like writing is in a league of its own; if Carbon is that strong, I'd consider upgrading to the Ultra plan.— blog ↗
- Impressive. — Elon Musk, replying to Sundar Pichai's Gemini 4 Carbon announcement.— x ↗
- You have once again announced a model we cannot use — I cannot fathom what motivates a lab whose recent releases haven't been competitive to shoot themselves in the foot like this.— hn ↗
- This model is not for you or me. This model is for Google AI engineers to put on their perf review at the end of the year.— hn ↗
- The benchmarks of a model that hasn't been released yet are definitely suspicious. Google should stop releasing models that aren't actually available.— hn ↗
- Without being able to access Carbon at announcement, there's no way to know the Carbon we get later is the same thing as what has been benchmarked.— hn ↗
- Even paying customers still can't use it!— hn ↗
“More capable and the same price — I can at least appreciate that.”
“Huge progress — first place on the terminal bench science benchmark.”
“You have once again announced a model we cannot use.”
FAQ
Is Gemini 4 Argon or Gemini 4 Carbon more worth it?
Gemini 4 Argon is more worth it, with a 40% worth-it score vs 39% for Gemini 4 Carbon.
How much does Gemini 4 Argon cost vs Gemini 4 Carbon?
Gemini 4 Argon: $2/$10 per 1M (→$4/$20 Dec 1) · Gemini 4 Carbon: $2/$10 per 1M (→$4/$20 Dec 1).
What do users say about Gemini 4 Argon vs Gemini 4 Carbon?
Gemini 4 Argon: $2/$10 per million tokens is a steal for what you get. Cheapest frontier model by a mile.. Gemini 4 Carbon: More capable and the same price — I can at least appreciate that..