Claude Sonnet 5.5 vs Gemini 4 Carbon

Comparer des modèles

Claude Sonnet 5.5 is more worth it — 63% vs 39%

How we score worth-it? →
63%Ça vaut le coup$2/$10 per 1M tokensÀ l'usage

Most loved — fast, but limits bite

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • Sonnet 5.5 is also a very nice worker improvement. It is probably on par with Opus 4.6-4.8.— hn
  • We have to test many different api's and models as we have over 600+ in our harness now, Sonnet 5.5 via cloud code provides the highest quality results.— hn
  • if I code with Claude (usually Sonnet 5.5-medium), Codex reviews it, and vice versa. I get much better code this way.— hn
  • I've come to terms with the fact that Sonnet 5.5 does most aspects of my job better than me and faster than me.— hn
  • Introducing Claude Sonnet 5.5 — 30%+ faster, costs up to 30% less per task, and scores 70.6% on Terminal-Bench 4.0.— reddit ↗
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • Smart and fast but very token-inefficient and expensive.— hn
  • Sonnet 5.5 is not worth using it unless at Low/Med effort.— reddit ↗
  • Opus 5.5 on Low seems smarter, cheaper, and faster than Sonnet on medium, so what's the point of Sonnet?— hn ↗
  • When you ask Claude Sonnet 5.5 to generate a small-to-medium-sized one-shot Python project, it will always fall into the same code patterns. Same structures of functions. Same file layout. Same package layout.— hn ↗

“The best daily-driver model, full stop. Fast, cheap enough, and the code is clean”

“Writing voice feels more human than other models. Doesn't sound like a thesaurus threw up”

“Rate limits are the killer. Try to run a long agent session and you're hitting a wall by lunch”

39%Ça vaut le coup$2/$10 per 1M (→$4/$20 Dec 1)À l'usage

Google's strongest frontier model — tops Intelligence Index v5, state-of-the-art cybersecurity + long coding. Gated to cyber defenders.

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • So more capable and the same price? I can at least appreciate that.— hn ↗
  • Huge progress, wow — first place on the terminal bench science benchmark.— blog ↗
  • I've been using Gemini 4 in AI Studio, and its human-like writing is in a league of its own; if Carbon is that strong, I'd consider upgrading to the Ultra plan.— blog ↗
  • Impressive. — Elon Musk, replying to Sundar Pichai's Gemini 4 Carbon announcement.— x ↗
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • You have once again announced a model we cannot use — I cannot fathom what motivates a lab whose recent releases haven't been competitive to shoot themselves in the foot like this.— hn ↗
  • This model is not for you or me. This model is for Google AI engineers to put on their perf review at the end of the year.— hn ↗
  • The benchmarks of a model that hasn't been released yet are definitely suspicious. Google should stop releasing models that aren't actually available.— hn ↗
  • Without being able to access Carbon at announcement, there's no way to know the Carbon we get later is the same thing as what has been benchmarked.— hn ↗
  • Even paying customers still can't use it!— hn ↗

“More capable and the same price — I can at least appreciate that.”

“Huge progress — first place on the terminal bench science benchmark.”

“You have once again announced a model we cannot use.”

FAQ

Is Claude Sonnet 5.5 or Gemini 4 Carbon more worth it?

Claude Sonnet 5.5 is more worth it, with a 63% worth-it score vs 39% for Gemini 4 Carbon.

How much does Claude Sonnet 5.5 cost vs Gemini 4 Carbon?

Claude Sonnet 5.5: $2/$10 per 1M tokens · Gemini 4 Carbon: $2/$10 per 1M (→$4/$20 Dec 1).

What do users say about Claude Sonnet 5.5 vs Gemini 4 Carbon?

Claude Sonnet 5.5: The best daily-driver model, full stop. Fast, cheap enough, and the code is clean. Gemini 4 Carbon: More capable and the same price — I can at least appreciate that..

Comparer des modèles →