Codex vs Devin
Comparer des modèles
Codex is more worth it — 68% vs 45%
How we score worth-it? →Reliable executor — lower ceiling, generous limits
- I've been coding for 30 years. Using Codex I'm finally enjoying it again for the first time in maybe 15 years. Outsource all that annoying part? Heck yeah - bring it on.— hn
- In my experience gpt5-codex (medium) and codex-cli is notably better than Sonnet 4.5 and claude-code. It is slower, but the results are much more often correct and it doesn't rush into half-baked solutions/dumb approaches as eagerly. I'd much rather wait 5 minutes than have to clean up manually.— hn
- I've been running Codex and Sonnet 4.5 side by side the past few weeks, and Codex gives me better results 90% of the time, pretty much across all tasks... Codex gets complex things right more consistently.— hn
- For a good month I juggled between Claude Code and Codex CLI and found that Codex CLI did the job better. I recently ditched Claude Code and am currently only using Codex CLI.— hn
- I was able to use it for few use cases where it got it right the first time. The ability to use a screenshot to create an application is nice for rapid prototyping.— hn ↗
- I've been quite unimpressed by Codex for now... the quality of the code is worse than Claude for me.— hn ↗
- I'm done. Codex was dumb as a rock today - on 6.1 it keeps stopping to report back, can't get through a single long task, and reports in again after every couple of file edits. Absolutely braindead.— v2ex ↗
“Great for kicking off background tasks and walking away”
“Predictable cost and generous limits — the budget pick for heavy use”
“But it feels lazy on complex reasoning. It'll take shortcuts you didn't ask for”
Autonomous software engineer
- They have gotten better, and Devin has some of the better UX. And for the record no ties to Devin/Cognition — just pay them too much as a customer.— hn
- Here we are 2 years later and Devin is great.— hn
- Devin/Cognition definitely have a legit AI dev agent now.— hn
- I've been using SWE 1.6 quite a lot for grunt work alongside Opus for higher level planning — a good combo.— hn
- This is the goal behind Devin Fusion, pretty good results so far I think.— hn
- My team tried it, my conclusions were: - it took just as much prompting as a using an LLM to get simple tasks done - took many hours to come to wrong conclusions for simple problems - the examples in their site are definitely cherry picked— hn
- They _are_ all wrappers around GPT-4/Claude. If you don't know what _you_ and the _AI_ is doing, you will not get anywhere.— hn
- learn programming before using devin it doesn't make websites but just simple instructions, you need to know what you're making.— hn
- o1 pro is 10x better— hn
- Given it was made by cognition (team behind devin flop) who now just got to wait out until claude and gpt5 do all of the work — not very.— hn
“Autonomous end-to-end coding actually works for delegated tickets.”
“Give it a clear issue and it'll open a PR by morning.”
“Pricey and aimed at teams, not solo devs.”
FAQ
Is Codex or Devin more worth it?
Codex is more worth it, with a 68% worth-it score vs 45% for Devin.
How much does Codex cost vs Devin?
Codex: Free · Plus $20/mo · API $1.75/$14 · Devin: Free · Pro $20/mo · Max $200/mo.
What do users say about Codex vs Devin?
Codex: Great for kicking off background tasks and walking away. Devin: Autonomous end-to-end coding actually works for delegated tickets..