MiniMax H3 vs Runway Gen-4.5
Comparer des modèles
MiniMax H3 is more worth it — 46% vs 36%
How we score worth-it? →Open-weight multimodal video generation with native stereo audio — text/image-to-video, 4–15s clips.
- Running this on my 4070ti super (16GB VRAM), it takes 10 minutes for a 10-second 480p video, but the results are spectacular.— hn ↗
- In the AMA MiniMax said H3 could support sparse attention — that would be a huge speedup. H3 is very cool.— hn ↗
- You landed like Prometheus giving us the power the gods were gatekeeping — I couldn't be more grateful for this immense gift.— huggingface ↗
- Minimax has the best prompt adherence from all open source models I've used — I never got bad prompt adherence.— huggingface ↗
- Being able to run at this level already makes me very happy and satisfied.— blog ↗
- We still do not know the correct objective for preserving its original CFG-distilled behavior — training can drift prompt adherence and temporal dynamics.— huggingface ↗
- When will the face collapse everyone complains about be fixed? If faces keep collapsing, what productivity value does it have?— huggingface ↗
- I can write stuff and the prompt is completely ignored. 99% of videos come out as a TV ad — I think that was the bulk of training data.— huggingface ↗
- Found a small flaw: a blinking problem — characters almost never blink.— huggingface ↗
- 4-bit quantization works, but it's slow to the point of tears. On an RTX PRO 5000, a 540p 15-second I2V takes 700 seconds.— v2ex ↗
“Minimax has the best prompt adherence from all open source models I've used.”
“Precise, high quality, few rerolls, high yield rate.”
“Face collapse that everyone complains about — if faces keep collapsing, what productivity value does it have?”
Pro video tool
- It has a stronger sense of shot logic than most models in the same tier. Gen-4.5 can make a short generated clip feel photographed.— blog
- Face consistency has improved a lot; characters in AI video finally stop drifting faces and can react properly across scenes.— blog
- Gen-4.5 delivers the best photorealism and prompt adherence of any commercial video model.— blog ↗
- The model's physics understanding is the best I've worked with commercially. Water flows with correct refraction; fabric drapes, folds, and catches wind convincingly.— blog ↗
- Prompt adherence is Gen-4.5's second superpower.— blog ↗
- Sigh, just what we need, even better fake videos.— hn
- Gen 4.5 doesn't ship with image-to-video at launch. For a creator workflow that depends on character and product consistency, that's a dealbreaker.— blog
- Complex motion is still the hardest thing in AI video. Limbs morphed mid-rotation, fingers blended into the dress.— blog
- Gen-4.5 sees physics but doesn't simulate them. It approximates.— blog
- Some objects vanish into thin air in complex backgrounds or action prompts, or a ball kicked off-target still goes into the goal.— blog
“Pro-grade video tooling for actual film workflows.”
“The control you get is unmatched if you're doing serious work.”
“Expensive for casual users — this is not a toy.”
FAQ
Is MiniMax H3 or Runway Gen-4.5 more worth it?
MiniMax H3 is more worth it, with a 46% worth-it score vs 36% for Runway Gen-4.5.
How much does MiniMax H3 cost vs Runway Gen-4.5?
MiniMax H3: $0.08/s (768P) · $0.13/s (2K) · Runway Gen-4.5: $0.12/sec.
What do users say about MiniMax H3 vs Runway Gen-4.5?
MiniMax H3: Minimax has the best prompt adherence from all open source models I've used.. Runway Gen-4.5: Pro-grade video tooling for actual film workflows..