Codex vs OpenAI dots
Compare models
Codex is more worth it — 58% vs 43%
How we score worth-it? →Reliable executor — lower ceiling, generous limits
- In my experience gpt5-codex (medium) and codex-cli is notably better than Sonnet 4.5 and claude-code. It is slower, but the results are much more often correct and it doesn't rush into half-baked solutions/dumb approaches as eagerly. I'd much rather wait 5 minutes than have to clean up manually.— hn
- I was able to use it for few use cases where it got it right the first time. The ability to use a screenshot to create an application is nice for rapid prototyping.— hn ↗
- Codex: a bit slow, but its instruction-following is quite good.— v2ex ↗
- By the time I moved to Codex, I felt the AI could handle UI design (frontend), implement features, and even test the project in the browser by itself.— v2ex ↗
- 我跟up主的感觉有点不一样,在我看还是Codex做事更稳一些。同样的提示词给到Codex和antigravity,出来的结果差异不小。Codex做事不急躁,稳扎稳打;而antigravity跟Gemini简直一个模子刻出来的,都是“谄媚+激进”。当然,这不是说antigravity不好,而是适合的任务与Codex不同。— bilibili ↗
- I've been quite unimpressed by Codex for now... the quality of the code is worse than Claude for me.— hn ↗
- I'm done. Codex was dumb as a rock today - on 6.1 it keeps stopping to report back, can't get through a single long task, and reports in again after every couple of file edits. Absolutely braindead.— v2ex ↗
- hi, just got 0.157.0, highlighting text in the TUI now has a pretty rough (~.5 seconds) latency. I copy the outputted text a lot, so this is a major pain point. Have to downgrade to 0.156.0 till this is fixed 😅— github ↗
“Great for kicking off background tasks and walking away”
“Predictable cost and generous limits — the budget pick for heavy use”
“But it feels lazy on complex reasoning. It'll take shortcuts you didn't ask for”
OpenAI's personal AI agent
- Main use case is orchestration for my life & my projects. Manages email, tracks todos/deadlines. I could see the use cases growing with time.— hn ↗
- I use the OpenAI one: Dot. It uses a very fast model... responds within a second or two... an always-on agent conversation.— hn ↗
- I used OpenAI Dots running GPT-6 Astra on Ultra reasoning mode, as an agent swarm with 6 subagents, to create a new mathematical proof.— hn ↗
- I personally prefer the business model of subscription payments funding my AI assistant, instead of skimming a fee off the top whenever it completes a purchase.— hn ↗
- I thought Meta Muse, OpenAI's Dot are solving consumer problems. Isn't it?— hn ↗
- Seems like a solution in search of a problem— hn ↗
- What a terrible marketing page. I read it a few times and still have zero idea what this thing is.— hn ↗
- The way that this is marketed at children is nothing short of evil.— hn ↗
- Ah, the continued pursuit of normalizing surveillance/becoming wholly reliant on a single service by making it cute with big eyes. Very tired of this already.— hn ↗
- I must be getting dumber as I get older. I genuinely can't work out what Dots actually is. It seems like a dumbed down reskin of Codex/ChatGPT Work but with the power-user features e.g. visibility/mentions removed. As a serious engineer why would I want that?— hn ↗
“OpenAI's personal agent — handles the boring stuff.”
“Email and scheduling are actually decent.”
“Still early, so it evolves week to week.”
Which should you pick?
The gap is clear: Codex sits at 58% while OpenAI dots is at 43%, a 15-point difference. If you just want the safer pick, start with Codex.
On entry price, Codex is cheaper ($20 vs $100, OpenAI dots costs about 400% more).
Both are in the Agent category with similar coverage; the real difference is stability and cost — run one of your own tasks through each before deciding.
What users actually said about Codex: "In my experience gpt5-codex (medium) and codex-cli is notably better than Sonnet 4.5 and c…"
FAQ
Is Codex or OpenAI dots more worth it?
Codex is more worth it, with a 58% worth-it score vs 43% for OpenAI dots.
How much does Codex cost vs OpenAI dots?
Codex: Free · Plus $20/mo · API $1.75/$14 · OpenAI dots: Included in Pro ($100–500/mo).
What do users say about Codex vs OpenAI dots?
Codex: Great for kicking off background tasks and walking away. OpenAI dots: OpenAI's personal agent — handles the boring stuff..