Codex vs Windsurf

Compare models

Codex is more worth it — 68% vs 51%

How we score worth-it? →
CodexAgent
68%Worth itFree · Plus $20/mo · API $1.75/$14Subscription

Reliable executor — lower ceiling, generous limits

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • I've been coding for 30 years. Using Codex I'm finally enjoying it again for the first time in maybe 15 years. Outsource all that annoying part? Heck yeah - bring it on.— hn
  • In my experience gpt5-codex (medium) and codex-cli is notably better than Sonnet 4.5 and claude-code. It is slower, but the results are much more often correct and it doesn't rush into half-baked solutions/dumb approaches as eagerly. I'd much rather wait 5 minutes than have to clean up manually.— hn
  • I've been running Codex and Sonnet 4.5 side by side the past few weeks, and Codex gives me better results 90% of the time, pretty much across all tasks... Codex gets complex things right more consistently.— hn
  • For a good month I juggled between Claude Code and Codex CLI and found that Codex CLI did the job better. I recently ditched Claude Code and am currently only using Codex CLI.— hn
  • I was able to use it for few use cases where it got it right the first time. The ability to use a screenshot to create an application is nice for rapid prototyping.— hn ↗
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • I've been quite unimpressed by Codex for now... the quality of the code is worse than Claude for me.— hn ↗
  • I'm done. Codex was dumb as a rock today - on 6.1 it keeps stopping to report back, can't get through a single long task, and reports in again after every couple of file edits. Absolutely braindead.— v2ex ↗

“Great for kicking off background tasks and walking away”

“Predictable cost and generous limits — the budget pick for heavy use”

“But it feels lazy on complex reasoning. It'll take shortcuts you didn't ask for”

51%Worth itFree · Pro $20/moSubscription

Fast, fluid AI IDE

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • As a (former) Windsurf user I'm pretty happy with the progress of the Cognition/Devin ecosystem after they took over Windsurf.— hn
  • This thing is insane. I spun up a Django project and accomplished in about 5 minutes what would normally take over an hour. The way it seamlessly edits multiple files in unison is unbelievably powerful.— hn
  • Today I had it build me an Angular component to recognize and decode barcodes through the device camera. It did an excellent job. I'm impressed.— hn
  • Tried Windsurf last night and damn, it just fixed translations perfectly without breaking anything else. Zero side effects.— hn
  • It's an easy example, but it outperforms my expectations. I think it's great.— hn
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • I canceled my Windsurf subscription. The recent comments by Scott Wu to the Windsurf team was the motivation I needed to move to zed/claude code.— hn
  • Devin/Cognition? All right, cancelled.— hn
  • I'd ask for trivial tasks and it would just get confused and delete stuff, or leave random UUID strings throughout the codebase.— hn
  • After about an hour with Windsurf, I find myself frustrated with how it deals with context. Very annoying to have the LLM try to create a file that already exists.— hn
  • Totally useless. It gets easily confused and cannot troubleshoot the environment. Don't depend on it for anything serious.— hn

“Fast, fluid, and the UX is genuinely pleasant to use”

“Cheaper than the big IDEs, which matters for students and startups”

“Smaller plugin ecosystem than the big two”

FAQ

Is Codex or Windsurf more worth it?

Codex is more worth it, with a 68% worth-it score vs 51% for Windsurf.

How much does Codex cost vs Windsurf?

Codex: Free · Plus $20/mo · API $1.75/$14 · Windsurf: Free · Pro $20/mo.

What do users say about Codex vs Windsurf?

Codex: Great for kicking off background tasks and walking away. Windsurf: Fast, fluid, and the UX is genuinely pleasant to use.

Compare models →