Devin vs Windsurf

Compare models

Windsurf is more worth it — 51% vs 45%

How we score worth-it? →
DevinAgent
45%Worth itFree · Pro $20/mo · Max $200/moSubscription

Autonomous software engineer

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • They have gotten better, and Devin has some of the better UX. And for the record no ties to Devin/Cognition — just pay them too much as a customer.— hn
  • Here we are 2 years later and Devin is great.— hn
  • Devin/Cognition definitely have a legit AI dev agent now.— hn
  • I've been using SWE 1.6 quite a lot for grunt work alongside Opus for higher level planning — a good combo.— hn
  • This is the goal behind Devin Fusion, pretty good results so far I think.— hn
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • My team tried it, my conclusions were: - it took just as much prompting as a using an LLM to get simple tasks done - took many hours to come to wrong conclusions for simple problems - the examples in their site are definitely cherry picked— hn
  • They _are_ all wrappers around GPT-4/Claude. If you don't know what _you_ and the _AI_ is doing, you will not get anywhere.— hn
  • learn programming before using devin it doesn't make websites but just simple instructions, you need to know what you're making.— hn
  • o1 pro is 10x better— hn
  • Given it was made by cognition (team behind devin flop) who now just got to wait out until claude and gpt5 do all of the work — not very.— hn

“Autonomous end-to-end coding actually works for delegated tickets.”

“Give it a clear issue and it'll open a PR by morning.”

“Pricey and aimed at teams, not solo devs.”

51%Worth itFree · Pro $20/moSubscription

Fast, fluid AI IDE

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • As a (former) Windsurf user I'm pretty happy with the progress of the Cognition/Devin ecosystem after they took over Windsurf.— hn
  • This thing is insane. I spun up a Django project and accomplished in about 5 minutes what would normally take over an hour. The way it seamlessly edits multiple files in unison is unbelievably powerful.— hn
  • Today I had it build me an Angular component to recognize and decode barcodes through the device camera. It did an excellent job. I'm impressed.— hn
  • Tried Windsurf last night and damn, it just fixed translations perfectly without breaking anything else. Zero side effects.— hn
  • It's an easy example, but it outperforms my expectations. I think it's great.— hn
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • I canceled my Windsurf subscription. The recent comments by Scott Wu to the Windsurf team was the motivation I needed to move to zed/claude code.— hn
  • Devin/Cognition? All right, cancelled.— hn
  • I'd ask for trivial tasks and it would just get confused and delete stuff, or leave random UUID strings throughout the codebase.— hn
  • After about an hour with Windsurf, I find myself frustrated with how it deals with context. Very annoying to have the LLM try to create a file that already exists.— hn
  • Totally useless. It gets easily confused and cannot troubleshoot the environment. Don't depend on it for anything serious.— hn

“Fast, fluid, and the UX is genuinely pleasant to use”

“Cheaper than the big IDEs, which matters for students and startups”

“Smaller plugin ecosystem than the big two”

FAQ

Is Devin or Windsurf more worth it?

Windsurf is more worth it, with a 51% worth-it score vs 45% for Devin.

How much does Devin cost vs Windsurf?

Devin: Free · Pro $20/mo · Max $200/mo · Windsurf: Free · Pro $20/mo.

What do users say about Devin vs Windsurf?

Devin: Autonomous end-to-end coding actually works for delegated tickets.. Windsurf: Fast, fluid, and the UX is genuinely pleasant to use.

Compare models →