GitHub Copilot vs Windsurf

Compare models

Windsurf is more worth it — 51% vs 29%

How we score worth-it? →
29%Worth itPro $10/mo · Pro+ $39/moSubscription

The default coding assistant

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • Documentation generation is the single most reliable use case.— hn
  • Their junior engineers now use Agent Mode to write the first pass of unit tests, then refine by hand. Test coverage went from 54% to 71% over two months.— hn
  • I love Copilot in VSCode. I just open the files, type what I want done, click accept on every code change. Couldn't possibly be simpler.— hn ↗
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • I wouldn't try it on anything larger, certainly my attempts to use it at refactoring haven't been great (very slow).— other ↗
  • The only thing that's fast with copilot is the autocomplete, it sometimes takes several minutes to make edits on a 100 line file regardless of the model.— hn ↗
  • Copilot has been pretty useless. It couldn't maintain context for more than two exchanges. When I ask for code, it hallucinates over half of the API calls.— hn ↗
  • So far, I am VERY unimpressed. It gets everything completely wrong and tells me lies and completely false information about my code.— hn ↗
  • It tends to indiscriminately use dependencies from random tiny repos, and often not the correct ones. buyer beware.— hn ↗

“Deep IDE and GitHub integration — it just works everywhere”

“The safe enterprise default. Legal teams are happy with it”

“But the agent mode still lags the top coding agents”

51%Worth itFree · Pro $20/moSubscription

Fast, fluid AI IDE

✅ Pros (real reviews)
  • As a (former) Windsurf user I'm pretty happy with the progress of the Cognition/Devin ecosystem after they took over Windsurf.— hn
  • This thing is insane. I spun up a Django project and accomplished in about 5 minutes what would normally take over an hour. The way it seamlessly edits multiple files in unison is unbelievably powerful.— hn
  • Today I had it build me an Angular component to recognize and decode barcodes through the device camera. It did an excellent job. I'm impressed.— hn
  • Tried Windsurf last night and damn, it just fixed translations perfectly without breaking anything else. Zero side effects.— hn
  • It's an easy example, but it outperforms my expectations. I think it's great.— hn
⚠️ Cons (real reviews)
  • I canceled my Windsurf subscription. The recent comments by Scott Wu to the Windsurf team was the motivation I needed to move to zed/claude code.— hn
  • Devin/Cognition? All right, cancelled.— hn
  • I'd ask for trivial tasks and it would just get confused and delete stuff, or leave random UUID strings throughout the codebase.— hn
  • After about an hour with Windsurf, I find myself frustrated with how it deals with context. Very annoying to have the LLM try to create a file that already exists.— hn
  • Totally useless. It gets easily confused and cannot troubleshoot the environment. Don't depend on it for anything serious.— hn

“Fast, fluid, and the UX is genuinely pleasant to use”

“Cheaper than the big IDEs, which matters for students and startups”

“Smaller plugin ecosystem than the big two”

FAQ

Is GitHub Copilot or Windsurf more worth it?

Windsurf is more worth it, with a 51% worth-it score vs 29% for GitHub Copilot.

How much does GitHub Copilot cost vs Windsurf?

GitHub Copilot: Pro $10/mo · Pro+ $39/mo · Windsurf: Free · Pro $20/mo.

What do users say about GitHub Copilot vs Windsurf?

GitHub Copilot: Deep IDE and GitHub integration — it just works everywhere. Windsurf: Fast, fluid, and the UX is genuinely pleasant to use.

Compare models →